Contact your Parish Council


Cabinet Report for Waste and Recycling Strategy 2010-2015 Appendix D

APPENDIX D

Waste and Recycling Strategy: Options Appraisal           

Option

Advantages

Disadvantages

Cost Implications

Impact on Recycling Rate

Retain existing service

No additional costs (other than standard contract uplift)

Maintain high customer satisfaction

Offers the council no savings.

The Council will not meet the national recycling target of 45% by 2015

Contract uplift on 31st July each year

Cost per household remains high

30%

Implementation of fortnightly residual waste collections

Offers significant savings to the council.

More efficient and cost effective service.

Significantly increases recycling rate through reduction in overall waste arisings

Public perception – customer satisfaction likely to fall based on Place Survey results elsewhere

Food waste would only be collected fortnightly increasing likelihood of smells and problems of waste not being contained within bin.

With this service alone, the council will not meet the national recycling target of 45% by 2015.

Savings in excess of £300,000 taking into account the set up costs.

Cost per household significantly reduces

38%

Implementation of weekly food waste collections alongside fortnightly residual waste collections

Increases amount sent for recycling – both food waste and mixed dry recycling.

Council will meet/exceed the national recycling target of 45% by 2015.

Maintains a weekly collection for the food waste which is most likely to cause smell and problems for residents – therefore should be perceived well by residents.

Encourages waste reduction and leads to less waste being disposed of.

Reduces disposal costs.

Will maintain/improve reputation of the council with Kent County Council and WRAP.

Does not offer any savings to the council.

As some residents have to remain on weekly service this creates a more complex service.

Potential issue with nappies being collected fortnightly.

Set up cost of £426,000 funded through WRAP and Kent Waste Partnership SIP fund.

Running costs for the food waste collections would be minimal due to the savings generated from fortnightly residual collections.  Further funding from Kent Waste Partnership is being sought to meet the operational costs of running the service.

Further savings in the core service operation will be sought within the context of the Best Value Review of waste.

45%

up to 50% with additional educational work and promotion of glass banks at recycling sites

Introduction of weekly food waste and fortnightly residual waste collections to 7000 households

Allows trial of scheme prior to re-tender of waste contract

Increases waste sent for recycling in trial area.

Maintains reputation with Kent County Council, WRAP and local residents

Different services operating across the borough will result in higher operational costs

Complexity of service increases – impact on contact centre and provision of information to residents

£118,000 Kent Waste Partnership SIP funding has been awarded as well as £70,000 WRAP funding which would cover the set up costs.

Running costs until 2013 are likely to be met by the savings generated from a reduction in one residual waste vehicle.

32%