Notes of the Informal Overview and Scrutiny Coordinating Committee
Wednesday 20 February 2013
Attendees: Councillors Mrs Blackmore, Burton, English, Mrs Gooch, D Mortimer and Paterson
Officers: Angela Woodhouse and Orla Sweeney
The Overview and Scrutiny Committee considered and debated a number of matters arising as a result of the resolution of full Council to develop a Cabinet with enhanced Scrutiny Model.
Vision
· Level of involvement
· Flexible
· Fit for purpose
Enhanced Scrutiny
· Effective Training
· Adequately resourced
· Early involvement in decisions
· Better relationship with Cabinet
· Using every tool we have available
· National support for / select committee, tools/advice/help
· Making a difference nationally
· Member Engagement
· Influencing outcomes/adding value
Which Model?
· Committees alighted to portfolios improve accountability
· But portfolios need reviewing
· How many?
· Do we need Advisory Committees? No use Scrutiny properly
Cabinet Member Accountability
· Number on Cabinet? Leader or an even responsibility
· Re-visit portfolios
· Portfolios and transparency
Scrutiny Chairman
· Exercise to develop JD
· 6 weekly co-ordinating committee daytime
Support for Scrutiny
· Democratic Services
· Resilience turn over plan 2 fte dedicated stay independent
Pre Decision Work Programme
· The CfPS approach was agreed as a constructive way forward
Member Apathy
· Open decision making process cabinet member meetings recording member input knowing whats coming up practical use the current period for pre-decision surgery quality and evidence base for the decision
· Appointment process application group dynamic
· The papers shouldnt need questions
· Expectations of officers member conduct groups training
· Induction process tailored - phased? mentoring?
Format & Style
· Read the papers
· Minutes
· Monthly meetings
· Pre-meet to identify issues/ideas as a guide and prompt inform & engage
· When to hold meetings
· Recommendation making on the topic as they come up
Work Programme P15
· Focus on issues members are interested in i.e. housing, planning policy
· Needs to change
· Get into the community
· 2 work streams
Forward Plan · Better engagement with cabinet · Monthly meetings fed back to scrutiny/involved |
Public issues Commissions |
Chairman
Good |
Bad |
Recommendation making that achieve outcomes (desirable) |
Allow to go off topic dominate questioning
|
ί Influencing (perception) ΰ
|
|
Guiding/shaping Acts fairly/order |
Ensure political (P) Minute taking
|
Desirable
|
|
· Suggesting holding consultation (public) · Ability to identify topics of public interest · Project Management · Ensures recs understand dec · Leadership
|
· Facilitator
· Arbitrate
· Adjudicate
· Mediate
· Motivate
· Allow participation
· Communication skills
· Involve (particularly new members)
· Keep control of meeting
· Good housekeeping
Appointment of Chairman
· Issue of the majority party taking the chairs
· Corporate services currently non-exec chair app
· Best person for job
· Policy over party
· There to facilitate
· Alternate?