Issue - meetings
Application to vary a premise licence under the Licensing Act 2003 for Hush Heath Winery, Hush Heath Estate, Five Oak Lane, Staplehurst, Kent, TN12 0HX.
Meeting: 10/09/2020 - Licensing Act 2003 Sub Committee (Item 27)
Additional documents:
- 1 Appendix - Hush Heath Variation Application, item 27 PDF 1 MB
- 2 Appendix - Current Plans, item 27 PDF 1 MB
- 3a Appendix - e-MAIL 10.8.20, item 27 PDF 31 KB View as HTML (27/4) 2 KB
- 3b Appendix - Letter of Objection August 2020 FINAL, item 27 PDF 232 KB
- 3c Appendix - Appendix 1 - Submissions bundle final (for hearing on 28 March)[56903], item 27 PDF 11 MB
- 3d Appendix - Appendix 2 - NOTICE OF DETERMINATION PREMISE(VARIATION) - 190328[56904], item 27 PDF 130 KB
- 3e Appendix - Appendix 3 - Note of Residents Meeting 20 01 2020[56905], item 27 PDF 139 KB
- 3f Appendix Appendix - e-MAIL 12.8.20, item 27 PDF 33 KB View as HTML (27/9) 2 KB
- 3g Appendix - 20 01678 LAPRE Residents Representation 12 08 2020, item 27 PDF 153 KB
- 4 Appendix - Staplehurst Parish Council Comments 11.8.20, item 27 PDF 53 KB View as HTML (27/11) 8 KB
- 5 Appendix - Current licence, item 27 PDF 101 KB
- 6 Appendix - Plan of the area Hush_Heath_Winery, item 27 PDF 151 KB
- 7 Appendix - Human Rights., item 27 PDF 30 KB View as HTML (27/14) 10 KB
- 8 Appendix - Order of Procedure of New and Variation Hearings, item 27 PDF 125 KB View as HTML (27/15) 39 KB
- NOTICE OF DETERMINATION PREMISES (VARIATION), item 27 PDF 117 KB View as HTML (27/16) 51 KB
Minutes:
The persons participating in the hearing were identified as follows:
Chairman – Councillor Joy
Committee Member – Councillor Springett
Committee Member – Councillor J Sams
Legal Advisor – Mr Robin Harris
Online Facilitator – Mr Ryan O’Connell
Democratic Services Officer – Miss Oliviya Parfitt
Applicant – Mr Richard Balfour-Lynn and Mrs Lesley Balfour-Lynn,
For the Applicant:
Mr Richard Balfour-Lynn – Owner of Hush Heath Winery
Mrs Leslie Balfour-Lynn – Owner of Hush Heath Winery
Sarah Easton - Winery Manager at Hush Heath Winery
Witnesses to be called by the Applicant:
Councillor John Perry – Staplehurst Ward Councillor and Vice-Chairman of Staplehurst Parish Council
Councillor Patrick Riordan – Chairman of Staplehurst Parish Council.
For the Objectors:
Mr Philip Kolvin QC – Acting on behalf of Angus Codd and Andrea Hodgkiss, Kim and Sally Humphrey, Alison Clark, Richard and Natasha Davidson-Houston, Amanda and Bernard Tipples, Frank and Ann Tipples, Dawn Lye, David Taylor and Nicola Feakin.
Witness to be called by the Objectors – Mrs Natasha Davidson-Houston
All parties confirmed that they were aware of the Sub-Committee hearing procedure and had each received a copy of the hearing procedure document.
The Chairman explained that:
· The Sub-Committee would allow all parties to put their case fully and make full submissions within a reasonable time frame.
· The procedure would take the form of a discussion led by the Sub-Committee and they would usually permit cross-examination conducted within a reasonable timeframe.
· Any persons attending the hearing who behaved in a disruptive manner may be directed to leave the hearing by the Sub-Committee (including temporarily) after which, such person may submit to the Sub-Committee over the Instant Messaging facility any information which that person would have been entitled to give orally had the person not been required to leave the meeting. If this is not possible, they may be permitted to speak at the Chairman’s Invitation.
The Sub-Committee confirmed that they had read all the papers.
The Chairman enquired whether any draft conditions had been agreed between the applicant and other parties; no draft conditions had been agreed.
The Legal Advisor outlined the variation application that had been received from Hush Heath Winery, which included an extension of hours and an amendment to the conditions of the licence held by the applicant. It was noted that 13 objections were received.
The applicant was invited to make their opening remarks and referenced the impact of the Coronavirus pandemic on his business which would lose approximately £925k this year. The reduction in sales to the tourist industry was of particular significance due to the businesses’ agricultural nature as a winery. The variation application had been submitted to allow for increased flexibility to enable the business to continue its operation. It was noted that prior to Covid-19, Mr Balfour-Lynn had previously informed local residents that there was no intention to amend the premises licence under which the business operated.
Mr Balfour-Lynn referenced the importance of the Winery for the local economy, which included employing local residents and ... view the full minutes text for item 27