
Agenda item
Report of the Head of Planning and Development - Maidstone Borough Local Plan - New and Amended Site Allocations
- Meeting of Cabinet., Wednesday 4th February, 2015 9.30 am (Item 120.)
- View the background to item 120.
(Please bring papers previously circulated). Appendix to the Decision is attached to this report.
Decision:
(1)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to the new
sites as set out in Appendix D agreement agreed by the Committee
with no changes to go to Regulation 18 Consultation and made the
following decisions:-
H1 (52) – Dunning Hall off Fremlin Walk, Week Street, Maidstone (14
units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be approved to go
forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 - Agreed
H1 (53) – 18-21 Foster Street, Maidstone (5 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (54) – Slencrest House, 3
Tonbridge Road, Maidstone (10 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (55) – Russell Hotel, Boxley Road, Maidstone (14 units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be approved to go forward to
Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (59) - Bearsted Station
Goods Yard (20 units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be approved to go forward to
Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (63) - Land at Boughton Mount, Boughton Lane,
Boughton Monchelsea (25 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to clarification of there being any legal covenants in
place that would prevent matters proceeding.
6 – Agreed
H1 (69) – Land at Lodge Road, Staplehurst (60
units)
RESOLVED: That the recommendation of the Committee
be rejected and that this new site should not be taken forward to
Regulation 18 consultation on the grounds that the site should be
retained for employment use given the economic upturn and that
infrastructure must be improved to enable this to happen and the
cumulative impact of residential development in Staplehurst on
social balance.
6 - Agreed
H1 (72) – Land adj. The Windmill PH, Eyhorne Street, Hollingbourne (15 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 -
Agreed
H1 (73) – Land at Brandy’s Bay, South Lane
(40 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18
Consultation.
6
– Agreed
(2)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent
Update to the report of the Head of
Planning and Development relating to new sites set out in Appendix
D agreed by the Committee with some changes to go to Regulation 18
Consultation and made the following decisions:-
H1 (51) – Bridge Industrial Centre, Wharf Road,
Tovil (15 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendments:-
Amend Criterion 5 to:
‘Vehicular access will be taken from Wharf Road
only. A secondary pedestrian and cycle
access capable of being used as an emergency access will be
provided from Lower Tovil’.
Amend Criterion 9 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Tovil Parish will be provided where proven
necessary’.
6 - Agreed
H1 (56) – Land at 180-188 Union Street, Maidstone
(30 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 10 to:
‘Appropriate air quality mitigation measures to include
appropriate planting and landscaping within the site will be
implemented as part of the development’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (58) – Tovil Working
Men’s Club, Tovil Hill,
Tovil (20 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 13 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Tovil Parish will be provided where proven
necessary’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (66) – Land South of the Parsonage,
Goudhurst Road, Marden (50
units)
RESOLVED: That the
recommendation of the Committee be rejected and that this new site
not be taken forward to Regulation 18 consultation on the grounds
that the site is too peripheral to Marden and on the grounds that
the cumulative impact of sites already considered in the draft
Local Plan would be unacceptable to the community in terms of
highways and water infrastructure and social balance.
5 – Agreed
1 – Abstained
H1 (70) – Land at Junction of Church Street and
Heath Road, Boughton Monchelsea (40 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 9 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Boughton Monchelsea
Parish will be provided where proven necessary’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (71) – Lyewood
Farm, Green Lane, Boughton Monchelsea (25 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 13 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Boughton Monchelsea
Parish will be provided where proven necessary’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (74) – Wren’s Cross, Upper Stone Street,
Maidstone (60 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to this site and others in the town centre and the locality
benefiting from a comprehensive assessment as part of a wider
master planning exercise.
6 – Agreed
(3)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to the new
sites set out in Appendix D agreed by the Committee which required
further information before acceptance to go to Regulation 18
Consultation and made the following decisions:-
H1 (62) – Land at Boughton Lane, Loose/Boughton
Monchelsea (75 units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be approved to go forward to
Regulation 18 Consultation subject to written confirmation on
junction improvements being sought from the Highway
Authority.
6 – Agreed
(4)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to the new
sites set out in Appendix D, rejected by the Committee and made the
following decisions:-
H1 (57) – Land at former Astor of Hever Community School, Maidstone (60
units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not be taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that the site is retained for education
use and development would be unacceptably compromised by the lack
of adequate access.
6 – Agreed
H1 (60) – Fant Farm,
Maidstone (225 units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be rejected and not taken
forward to Regulation 18 consultation on the grounds that the site
is valuable for agriculture use, and would have an unacceptable
impact on the landscape, including the overall shape of the urban
area of Maidstone and the unacceptable highways impact for the
local community.
6 – Agreed
H1 (61) – Land at Cross Keys, Bearsted (50 units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be rejected and not taken
forward to Regulation 18 consultation on the grounds that
development of this site would have an unacceptable impact on
hydrology and local flood risk.
3 – Agreed
3 – Against
(Chairman had the casting vote)
H1 (64) – Bell Farm North, East Street,
Harrietsham (80 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that the cumulative impact of
development having a detrimental effect on the character, size and
shape of the village and community due to the increase in size and
footprint of the village and unacceptable cumulative impact for the
community for education provision, transport and other community
infrastructure.
6 – Agreed
H1 (65) – Land at Lenham Road, Headcorn (50
units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that development is in reality
impractical due to current water conditions and community
perception of failure of infrastructure providers to deliver
infrastructure identified as required in the past, local knowledge
of flood risk and community concern about the cumulative impact on
local education provision and highways.
6 – Agreed
H1 (67) – Land to South of Marden Road,
Staplehurst (100 units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be rejected and not taken
forward to Regulation 18 consultation on the grounds that it has
not been demonstrated to the community’s satisfaction that
current foul water problems can be resolved and these will be
exacerbated by any further development in this part of Staplehurst
and the unacceptable cumulative impact for the community and
highways.
6 – Agreed
H1 (68) – Land to the North of Henhurst Farm, Staplehurst (60 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that it has not been demonstrated to
the community’s satisfaction that current foul water problems
can be resolved and these will be exacerbated by any further
development in this part of Staplehurst and the unacceptable
cumulative impact for the community and highways. In addition of
community concerns that suitable highways access arrangements
cannot be achieved at this point in time.
6 – Agreed
(5)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to
Regulation 18 Sites set out in Appendix D which Committee agreed
for Regulation 19 Consultation with no changes and made the
following decisions:-
H1 (2) – East of Hermitage Lane, Maidstone (500
units)
RESOLVED: Members noted
that this site was the subject of an appeal and whilst keen not to
prejudice any outcome of the appeal, they were in agreement that
the draft allocation should proceed to Regulation 19
consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (14) – American Golf, Tonbridge Road,
Maidstone (60 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (15) – 6 Tonbridge Road, Maidstone (15
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (18) - Whitmore Street, Maidstone (5
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (23) – New Line Learning, Boughton Lane (220
units)
RESOLVED: Members noted
that this site was the subject of an appeal and whilst keen not to
prejudice any outcome of the appeal, they were in agreement that
the draft allocation should proceed to Regulation 19
consultation.
H1 (27) – Mayfield Nursery, Ashford Road,
Harrietsham (50 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (35) - Marden Cricket & Hockey Club, Stanley
Road, Marden (125 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (46) – Vicarage Road, Yalding (65
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to additional references to traffic analysis and provision
of a community centre where proven necessary and adjustment of the
housing yield should this become necessary.
6 – Agreed
H1 (47) – Hubbards
Lane/Haste Hill Road, Boughton Monchelsea (20
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the addition of appropriate contribution improvements at
the junction of the B2163 Heath Road with the A229 Linton
Road/Linton Hill at Linton Crossroads.
6 – Agreed
H1 (49) – East of Eyhorne Street, Eyhorne
Street, Hollingbourne (10
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
(6)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to
Regulation 18 Sites set out in Appendix D which Committee agreed
for Regulation 19 Consultation with changes recommended by Officers
and made the following decisions:-
H1 (1) – Bridge Nursery, London Road, Maidstone
(165 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being reduced to 140 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (3) – West of Hermitage Lane, Maidstone (300
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being increased to 330 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (5) - Langley Park, Sutton Road, Maidstone (600
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the following new criterion:-
‘A separate cycle and pedestrian access will be provided to
site H1 (10) South of Sutton Road subject to agreement with the
highways authority and the Borough Council’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (6) – North of Sutton Road, Otham (285 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being increased to 286 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (16) – Laguna, Hart Street, Maidstone (55
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being increased to 76 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (19) – North Street, Barming (35
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the amended site plan which clarifies the linear
development as set out in the papers.
6 - Agreed
H1 (21) – Kent Police HQ, Sutton Road (115
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being reduced to 112 as per the
papers.
6 - Agreed
H1 (22) – Kent Police Training Centre, Sutton
Road, Maidstone (70 units)
RESOLVED: That this site be
approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to the
revised yield being increased to 90 as per the papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (28) – Church Road, Harrietsham (95
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 80 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (32) – Howland Road, Marden (55
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 44, from 55 as per
Appendix B of the original agenda.
Members noted that the supplementary papers contained a typing
error and that the yield should have stated 44 instead of 80.
6 - Agreed
H1 (33) – Stanley Farm, Plain Road, Marden (170
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 85 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (34) – The Parsonage, Goudhurst Road, Marden (200 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 144 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (38) – Old School Nursery, Station Road,
Headcorn (5 units)
RESOLVED: That this site be
approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to the
revised yield being increased to 9 as per the papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (50) – West of Eyhorne Street, Eyhorne
Street, Hollingbourne (35
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 14 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
(7)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to
Regulation 18 Sites set out in Appendix D which Committee agreed
with changes recommended by Officers for further Regulation 18
consultation and made the following decisions:-
H1 (10) – South of Sutton Road (930 units)
RESOLVED: That the
recommendations of the Committee for this site to go forward to
further Regulation 18 consultation be rejected and that this site
go forward to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion on the
grounds that:-
(a)
in the opinion of the Cabinet the eastern boundary of
site H1 (5) forms a natural boundary to the edge of
the urban area of Maidstone;
(b)
there should be no further encroachment of residential
development into the countryside which would result in
the loss of green space and a leisure facility;
(c)
there would be an unacceptable cumulative impact on
traffic generations in the Sutton Road corridor;
(d)
there would be an unacceptable impact on conditions
in the surrounding area where the environmental and
amenity consequences for the community are
unacceptable now; and
(e)
that development here would not command the
consent of local people as reflected in the consultation
response.
4 – Agreed
1 – Against
(Councillor Burton left the meeting at the start of this item after
disclosing an other significant interest).
H1 (11) – Springfield, Royal Engineers Road and
Mill Way (950 units)
RESOLVED: That the
recommendation of Committee for this site to be put forward to
Regulation 18 be rejected and instead go forward to Regulation 19
consultation on the revised reduced yield of 500 units and subject
to an amendment to Criterion 10 as set out in the Urgent Update
Report which is as follows:-
‘Provision of publicly accessible open space to include the
provision of a pocket park to the rear (west) of the existing
Springfield Mansion on the former tennis court/car park area in
addition to the existing area of public open space shown on the
proposals map which shall be retained as part of the development
and/or contributions.
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
H1 (40) Grigg Lane and Lenham Road, Headcorn (120
units)
RESOLVED: That Members
opted to debate the allocated site as two separate considerations
as follows:-
Southern portion of the site, consisting of two granted planning
consents for 45 units go forward to Regulation 19 consultation;
and
That the remaining northern portion of the site, where no consents
exist, go back to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion, on the
grounds that it has not been demonstrated to the community’s
satisfaction that current foul water problems can be resolved and
these will be exacerbated by any further development in this part
of Headcorn and the unacceptable cumulative impact for the
community and highways. In addition of community concerns that
suitable highways access arrangements cannot be achieved at this
point in time.
4 – Agreed
2 – Abstained
H1 (48) – Heath Road, Boughton Monchelsea (25
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go back to Regulation 18 for deletion.
6 - Agreed
(8)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent
Update to the report of the Head of
Planning and Development relating to Regulation 18 Sites set out in
Appendix D which Committee agreed for
Regulation 19 consultation with changes and made the following
decisions:-
H1 (4) – Land at Oakapple Lane, Barming (240 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation, if necessary
reconsidered in the light of the outcome of the Public Inquiry for
Site H1 (2) and continuing dialogue with Tonbridge & Malling
Borough Council.
6 - Agreed
H1 (7) – Land North of Bicknor Wood, Otham
(190 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation, with the criterion
amended as set out in the papers and that the following be added to
Criterion 12 as follows:-
‘strategic transport requirements, adding in point vii:
strategic road infrastructure to significantly relieve traffic
congestion on Sutton Road and Willington Street’
5 – Agreed
1 – Against
H1 (8) – Land West of Church Road, Otham (440 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation with the criterion
amended as set out in the papers and that at Criterion 10,
paragraph vii be added:
‘strategic road infrastructure to significantly relieve
traffic congestion on Sutton Road and Willington
Street’.
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
H1 (9) – Bicknor Farm, Sutton
Road (335 units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation with the criterion amended as set out
in the papers and that at Criterion 12, paragraph vii be
added:
‘strategic road infrastructure to significantly relieve
traffic congestion on Sutton Road and Willington
Street’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (12) – Haynes, Ashford Road (250 units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation with a revised reduced yield of 200
units and incorporating the changes to the policy criterion as
follows:-
‘Provision will be made for publicly accessible open space
within the development site as part of the development layout and
contributions off-site where proven necessary’
And adding criterion:
‘The layout will be designed to ensure built development is
set-back from the Ashford Road frontage’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (13) – Medway Street, Maidstone (40
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation incorporating an
additional criterion as follows:-
‘The development layout will include significant landscaping
including tree planting’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (24) – West of Eclipse Park, Sittingbourne
Road (35 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation incorporating amended
criterion 2 as follows:-
‘A minimum 15 metre landscape buffer
shall be provided along the site’s western boundary adjacent
to the ancient woodland and no footpath, cycle or track-way shall
be provided within this safeguarded area’.
Additional criterion:
‘The layout and landscaping of the site shall be designed to
minimise the impact of development on the adjacent ancient woodland
to the west of the site through appropriate siting of the built development’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (29) – Tanyard Farm, Old
Ashford Road, Lenham (155 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to the
amended and additional criterions as per the papers and subject to
Ward Members being consulted on the landscaping issues:-
‘The hedgerow and line of trees along the northern and
southern boundaries of the site will be retained and substantially
enhanced by new planting in order to protect the setting of the
Kent Downs AONB, and to provide a suitable buffer between new
housing and the A20 Ashford Road and Old Ashford Road’.
‘The development proposals shall be designed to maintain
existing vistas and views of the Lenham Cross from Old Ashford
Road, through the site and along PROW KH433.
Development proposals shall incorporate substantial areas of
internal landscaping within the site to provide an appropriate
landscape framework for the site to protect the setting of the Kent
Downs AONB Development proposals will be of a highway standard of
design and sustainability reflecting the location of the site as
part of the setting the Kent Downs AONB incorporating the use of
vernacular materials and demonstrating compliance with the
requirements of policies DM2, DM3 and DM4.
The development proposals are designed to take into account the
results of a landscape and visual impact assessment undertaken in
accordance with the principles of current guidance that
particularly addresses the impact of development on the character
and setting of the Kent Downs AONB’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (36) – Hen and Duckhurst Farm, Marden Road, Staplehurst (370
units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation on a revised reduced yield of 250
units as per the papers. In addition
amend the Criterion 11 to:
‘appropriate contributions towards community strategic
infrastructure in particular foul water drainage will be provided
where proven necessary so that there is nil detriment to existing
infrastructure capacity’.
4 – Agreed
1 – Against
1 – Abstained
H1 (37) – Fishers Farm, Fishers Road, Staplehurst
(535 units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation on a revised reduced yield of a
maximum of 400 units. In addition amend the Criterion 11
to:
‘appropriate contributions towards community strategic
infrastructure in particular foul water drainage will be provided
where proven necessary so that there is nil detriment to existing
infrastructure capacity’.
An additional criterion as follows:-
‘The proposals will be designed to include areas of open
space that retain the integrity and connectivity of the existing
framework of ponds, hedgerows and trees within the
site’.
6 - Agreed
H1 (43) – Linden Farm, Stockett Lane, Coxheath (85 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation on a revised reduced
yield of 40 with an additional criterion as per the papers of
appropriate contributions towards improvements at the junction of
the B2163 Heath Road, with the A229 Linton Road/Linton Hill at
Linton Crossroads and a cascade criterion for community
infrastructure with investment in Coxheath first unless proven
otherwise.
6 – Agreed
H1 (44) – Heathfield,
Heath Road, Coxheath (130 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to amended
criterion as per the papers and a cascade criterion for community
infrastructure with investment in Coxheath first unless proven
otherwise.
H1 (26) – South of Ashford Road, Harrietsham (70
units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation on the revised increased yield of 117
units and that an additional criterion be added as follows:-
‘The site layout is designed to fully integrate the
development and the proposed improvements to the A20 Ashford Road
to ensure a comprehensive approach to the improvements of the
public realm and highways safety’
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
(9)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent
Update to the report of the Head of
Planning and Development relating to Regulation 18 Sites set out in
Appendix D which Committee recommended for further Regulation 18
consultation on deletion of the site from the Local Plan and made
the following decisions:-
H1 (17) – Barty Farm,
Roundwell (122 units)
RESOLVED: That Members
rejected the recommendation of the Committee and that the site go
forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to amendment of the
site policy to respond to concerns about future primary education
provision and an additional criterion that Section 106
contributions are spent in Thurnham and
Bearsted first unless proven
otherwise.
5 – Agreed
1 – Against
H1 (20) – Postley
Road, Tovil (80
units)
RESOLVED: That Members
rejected the recommendation of the Committee and that the site go
forward to Regulation 19 consultation on the revised reduced yield
of 62 as per the papers.
4 – Agreed
1 - Against
1 - Abstained
6 – Agreed
H1 (25) – Tongs Meadow, West Street, Harrietsham (100
units)
RESOLVED: That Members, whilst
noting the concerns about ecology, were satisfied that there was
sufficient protection in the site policy and moved to reject the
recommendation of the Committee and that the site go forward to
Regulation 19 consultation with the amendments to criterion 4 as
per the papers and for a revised increased yield of 105.
5 – Agreed
1 – Against
H1 (30) – Glebe Gardens, Lenham (10
units)
RESOLVED: That Members rejected the
recommendation of the Committee and that the site go forward to
Regulation 19 consultation. It was
noted that the current planning application for this site provided
details of the proposed works to the pond and its environs and
other ecological surveys. These will be
considered as part of the application process by appropriate
consultees including the Environment
Agency and KCC Ecology, to-date no fundamental objections have been
raised to the principle of development as set out in the
policy.
6 – Agreed
H1 (31) – Ham Lane, Lenham (80
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be rejected and go back to Regulation 18 consultation for
deletion on the grounds of unacceptably adverse impact on the AONB
and on the character of the village because it is peripheral to the
settlement and beyond the open space occupied by Swadelands School playing field.
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
H1 (39) – Ulcombe Road and Mill Bank, Headcorn (240
units)
RESOLVED: That Members
reject this site after further information was received at the
adjourned meeting which related to a drainage survey undertaken by
Headcorn Parish Council that detailed all the pipework across the Headcorn area. It was noted that a copy had been passed to
Southern Water. It was agreed to go
back to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion on the grounds that
local infrastructure is insufficient, in particular for foul water
sewerage, flood risk and highway congestion
.
3 – Agreed
3 – Against
(Chairman had the casting vote)
H1 (41) – South of Grigg Lane, Headcorn (55
units)
RESOLVED: That this site be
rejected and go back to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion on
the grounds that local infrastructure is insufficient, in
particular for foul water sewerage, flood risk and highway
congestion.
3 – Agreed
2 – Against
1 – Abstained
H1 (42) Knaves Acre, Headcorn (5 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be rejected and go back to Regulation 18 consultation for
deletion on the grounds that local infrastructure is insufficient,
in particular for foul water sewerage, flood risk and highway
congestion.
3 – Agreed
2 – Against
1 – Abstained
H1 (45) – Forstal Lane, Coxheath
(195 units)
RESOLVED: That Members
rejected the recommendation of the Committee and that the site go
forward to Regulation 19 consultation with the amended criterion as
per the papers of appropriate contributions towards improvements at
the junction of the B2163 Heath Road, with the A229 Linton
Road/Linton Hill at Linton Crossroads and a cascade criterion for
community infrastructure with investment in Coxheath first unless
proven otherwise.
3 – Agreed
2 – Against
1 – Abstained
(10)
That the shortfall of 2,556 homes against the already agreed
housing objectively assessed need of 18,600 was noted (for clarity
attached as Appendix A to this decision is a table setting out the
decision for the yield on each site) and Officers were asked to
bring a further report to Cabinet as soon as possible which
outlines the associated risks to the delivery of a sound Local
Plan; and
That Officers urgently progress dialogue with
infrastructure
providers, particularly in relation to foul water, specifically
for
Headcorn and Staplehurst, to ensure that existing
infrastructure
concerns are addressed and works are progressed with the
utmost urgency.
Minutes:
Following on from their meeting held on 2 February 2015, Cabinet continued to consider the Report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to Maidstone Borough Local Plan – New and Amended Site Allocations.
DECISION MADE:
(1)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to the new
sites as set out in Appendix D agreement agreed by the Committee
with no changes to go to Regulation 18 Consultation and made the
following decisions:-
H1 (52) – Dunning Hall off Fremlin Walk, Week Street, Maidstone (14
units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be approved to go
forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 - Agreed
H1 (53) – 18-21 Foster Street, Maidstone (5
units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (54) – Slencrest House, 3 Tonbridge Road, Maidstone (10
units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (55) – Russell Hotel, Boxley Road, Maidstone (14 units)
RESOLVED: That this new site be
approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (59) - Bearsted Station
Goods Yard (20 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (63) - Land at Boughton Mount, Boughton Lane,
Boughton Monchelsea (25 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to clarification of there being any legal covenants in
place that would prevent matters proceeding.
6 – Agreed
H1 (69) – Land at Lodge Road, Staplehurst (60
units)
RESOLVED: That the recommendation of the Committee
be rejected and that this new site should not be taken forward to
Regulation 18 consultation on the grounds that the site should be
retained for employment use given the economic upturn and that
infrastructure must be improved to enable this to happen and the
cumulative impact of residential development in Staplehurst on
social balance.
6 - Agreed
H1 (72) – Land adj. The Windmill PH, Eyhorne Street, Hollingbourne (15 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation.
6 - Agreed
H1 (73) – Land at Brandy’s Bay, South Lane
(40 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18
Consultation.
6
– Agreed
(2)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent
Update to the report of the Head of
Planning and Development relating to new sites set out in Appendix
D agreed by the Committee with some changes to go to Regulation 18
Consultation and made the following decisions:-
H1 (51) – Bridge Industrial Centre, Wharf Road,
Tovil (15 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendments:-
Amend Criterion 5 to:
‘Vehicular access will be taken from Wharf Road
only. A secondary pedestrian and cycle
access capable of being used as an emergency access will be
provided from Lower Tovil’.
Amend Criterion 9 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Tovil Parish will be provided where proven
necessary’.
6 - Agreed
H1 (56) – Land at 180-188 Union Street, Maidstone
(30 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 10 to:
‘Appropriate air quality mitigation measures to include
appropriate planting and landscaping within the site will be
implemented as part of the development’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (58) – Tovil Working
Men’s Club, Tovil Hill,
Tovil (20 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 13 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Tovil Parish will be provided where proven
necessary’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (66) – Land South of the Parsonage,
Goudhurst Road, Marden (50
units)
RESOLVED: That the
recommendation of the Committee be rejected and that this new site
not be taken forward to Regulation 18 consultation on the grounds
that the site is too peripheral to Marden and on the grounds that
the cumulative impact of sites already considered in the draft
Local Plan would be unacceptable to the community in terms of
highways and water infrastructure and social balance.
5 – Agreed
1 – Abstained
H1 (70) – Land at Junction of Church Street and
Heath Road, Boughton Monchelsea (40 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 9 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Boughton Monchelsea
Parish will be provided where proven necessary’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (71) – Lyewood
Farm, Green Lane, Boughton Monchelsea (25 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to the following amendment:-
Amend Criterion 13 to:
‘Appropriate contributions towards community infrastructure
including improvement to medical facilities in Boughton Monchelsea
Parish will be provided where proven necessary’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (74) – Wren’s Cross, Upper Stone Street,
Maidstone (60 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to this site and others in the town centre and the locality
benefiting from a comprehensive assessment as part of a wider
master planning exercise.
6 – Agreed
(3)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to the new
sites set out in Appendix D agreed by the Committee which required
further information before acceptance to go to Regulation 18
Consultation and made the following decisions:-
H1 (62) – Land at Boughton Lane, Loose/Boughton
Monchelsea (75 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 18 Consultation
subject to written confirmation on junction improvements being
sought from the Highway Authority.
6 – Agreed
(4)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to the new
sites set out in Appendix D, rejected by the Committee and made the
following decisions:-
H1 (57) – Land at former Astor of Hever Community School, Maidstone (60
units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not be taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that the site is retained for education
use and development would be unacceptably compromised by the lack
of adequate access.
6 – Agreed
H1 (60) – Fant Farm,
Maidstone (225 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that the site is valuable for
agriculture use, and would have an unacceptable impact on the
landscape, including the overall shape of the urban area of
Maidstone and the unacceptable highways impact for the local
community.
6 – Agreed
H1 (61) – Land at Cross Keys, Bearsted (50 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that development of this site would
have an unacceptable impact on hydrology and local flood
risk.
3 – Agreed
3 – Against
(Chairman had the casting vote)
H1 (64) – Bell Farm North, East Street,
Harrietsham (80 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that the cumulative impact of
development having a detrimental effect on the character, size and
shape of the village and community due to the increase in size and
footprint of the village and unacceptable cumulative impact for the
community for education provision, transport and other community
infrastructure.
6 – Agreed
H1 (65) – Land at Lenham Road, Headcorn (50
units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that development is in reality
impractical due to current water conditions and community
perception of failure of infrastructure providers to deliver
infrastructure identified as required in the past, local knowledge
of flood risk and community concern about the cumulative impact on
local education provision and highways.
6 – Agreed
H1 (67) – Land to South of Marden Road,
Staplehurst (100 units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that it has not been demonstrated to
the community’s satisfaction that current foul water problems
can be resolved and these will be exacerbated by any further
development in this part of Staplehurst and the unacceptable
cumulative impact for the community and highways.
6 – Agreed
H1 (68) – Land to the North of Henhurst Farm, Staplehurst (60
units)
RESOLVED: That this new
site be rejected and not taken forward to Regulation 18
consultation on the grounds that it has not been demonstrated to
the community’s satisfaction that current foul water problems
can be resolved and these will be exacerbated by any further
development in this part of Staplehurst and the unacceptable
cumulative impact for the community and highways. In addition of
community concerns that suitable highways access arrangements
cannot be achieved at this point in time.
6 – Agreed
(5)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to
Regulation 18 Sites set out in Appendix D which Committee agreed
for Regulation 19 Consultation with no changes and made the
following decisions:-
H1 (2) – East of Hermitage Lane, Maidstone (500
units)
RESOLVED: Members noted
that this site was the subject of an appeal and whilst keen not to
prejudice any outcome of the appeal, they were in agreement that
the draft allocation should proceed to Regulation 19
consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (14) – American Golf, Tonbridge Road,
Maidstone (60 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (15) – 6 Tonbridge Road, Maidstone (15
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (18) - Whitmore Street, Maidstone (5
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (23) – New Line Learning, Boughton Lane (220
units)
RESOLVED: Members noted
that this site was the subject of an appeal and whilst keen not to
prejudice any outcome of the appeal, they were in agreement that
the draft allocation should proceed to Regulation 19
consultation.
H1 (27) – Mayfield Nursery, Ashford Road,
Harrietsham (50 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (35) - Marden Cricket & Hockey Club, Stanley
Road, Marden (125 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
H1 (46) – Vicarage Road, Yalding (65
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to additional references to traffic analysis and provision
of a community centre where proven necessary and adjustment of the
housing yield should this become necessary.
6 – Agreed
H1 (47) – Hubbards
Lane/Haste Hill Road, Boughton Monchelsea (20
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the addition of appropriate contribution improvements at
the junction of the B2163 Heath Road with the A229 Linton
Road/Linton Hill at Linton Crossroads.
6 – Agreed
H1 (49) – East of Eyhorne Street, Eyhorne
Street, Hollingbourne (10
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation.
6 – Agreed
(6)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to
Regulation 18 Sites set out in Appendix D which Committee agreed
for Regulation 19 Consultation with changes recommended by Officers
and made the following decisions:-
H1 (1) – Bridge Nursery, London Road, Maidstone
(165 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being reduced to 140 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (3) – West of Hermitage Lane, Maidstone (300
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being increased to 330 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (5) - Langley Park, Sutton Road, Maidstone (600
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the following new criterion:-
‘A separate cycle and pedestrian access will be provided to
site H1 (10) South of Sutton Road subject to agreement with the
highways authority and the Borough Council’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (6) – North of Sutton Road, Otham (285 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being increased to 286 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (16) – Laguna, Hart Street, Maidstone (55
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being increased to 76 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (19) – North Street, Barming (35
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the amended site plan which clarifies the linear
development as set out in the papers.
6 - Agreed
H1 (21) – Kent Police HQ, Sutton Road (115
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being reduced to 112 as per the
papers.
6 - Agreed
H1 (22) – Kent Police Training Centre, Sutton
Road, Maidstone (70 units)
RESOLVED: That this site be
approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to the
revised yield being increased to 90 as per the papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (28) – Church Road, Harrietsham (95
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 80 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (32) – Howland Road, Marden (55
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 44, from 55 as per
Appendix B of the original agenda.
Members noted that the supplementary papers contained a typing
error and that the yield should have stated 44 instead of 80.
6 - Agreed
H1 (33) – Stanley Farm, Plain Road, Marden (170
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 85 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (34) – The Parsonage, Goudhurst Road, Marden (200 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 144 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (38) – Old School Nursery, Station Road,
Headcorn (5 units)
RESOLVED: That this site be
approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to the
revised yield being increased to 9 as per the papers.
6 – Agreed
H1 (50) – West of Eyhorne Street, Eyhorne
Street, Hollingbourne (35
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be approved to go forward to Regulation 19 consultation
subject to the revised yield being decreased to 14 as per the
papers.
6 – Agreed
(7)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent Update to the
report of the Head of Planning and Development relating to
Regulation 18 Sites set out in Appendix D which Committee agreed
with changes recommended by Officers for further Regulation 18
consultation and made the following decisions:-
H1 (10) – South of Sutton Road (930 units)
RESOLVED: That the
recommendations of the Committee for this site to go forward to
further Regulation 18 consultation be rejected and that this site
go forward to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion on the
grounds that:-
(a)
in the opinion of the Cabinet the eastern boundary of
site H1 (5) forms a natural boundary to the edge of
the urban area of Maidstone;
(b)
there should be no further encroachment of residential
development into the countryside which would result in
the loss of green space and a leisure facility;
(c)
there would be an unacceptable cumulative impact on
traffic generations in the Sutton Road corridor;
(d)
there would be an unacceptable impact on conditions
in the surrounding area where the environmental and
amenity consequences for the community are
unacceptable
now; and
(e)
that development here would not command the
consent of local people as reflected in the consultation
response.
4 – Agreed
1 – Against
(Councillor Burton left the meeting at the start of this item after
disclosing an other significant interest).
H1 (11) – Springfield, Royal Engineers Road and
Mill Way (950 units)
RESOLVED: That the
recommendation of Committee for this site to be put forward to
Regulation 18 be rejected and instead go forward to Regulation 19
consultation on the revised reduced yield of 500 units and subject
to an amendment to Criterion 10 as set out in the Urgent Update
Report which is as follows:-
‘Provision of publicly accessible open space to include the
provision of a pocket park to the rear (west) of the existing
Springfield Mansion on the former tennis court/car park area in
addition to the existing area of public open space shown on the
proposals map which shall be retained as part of the development
and/or contributions.
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
H1 (40) Grigg Lane and Lenham Road, Headcorn (120
units)
RESOLVED: That Members
opted to debate the allocated site as two separate considerations
as follows:-
Southern portion of the site, consisting of two granted planning
consents for 45 units go forward to Regulation 19 consultation;
and
That the remaining northern portion of the site, where no consents
exist, go back to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion, on the
grounds that it has not been demonstrated to the community’s
satisfaction that current foul water problems can be resolved and
these will be exacerbated by any further development in this part
of Headcorn and the unacceptable cumulative impact for the
community and highways. In addition of community concerns that
suitable highways access arrangements cannot be achieved at this
point in time.
4 – Agreed
2 – Abstained
H1 (48) – Heath Road, Boughton Monchelsea (25
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go back to Regulation 18 for deletion.
6 - Agreed
(8)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent
Update to the report of the Head of
Planning and Development relating to Regulation 18 Sites set out in
Appendix D which Committee agreed for
Regulation 19 consultation with changes and made the following
decisions:-
H1 (4) – Land at Oakapple Lane, Barming (240 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation, if necessary
reconsidered in the light of the outcome of the Public Inquiry for
Site H1 (2) and continuing dialogue with Tonbridge & Malling
Borough Council.
6 - Agreed
H1 (7) – Land North of Bicknor Wood, Otham
(190 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation, with the criterion
amended as set out in the papers and that the following be added to
Criterion 12 as follows:-
‘strategic transport requirements, adding in point vii:
strategic road infrastructure to significantly relieve traffic
congestion on Sutton Road and Willington Street’
5 – Agreed
1 – Against
H1 (8) – Land West of Church Road, Otham (440 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation with the criterion
amended as set out in the papers and that at Criterion 10,
paragraph vii be added:
‘strategic road infrastructure to significantly relieve
traffic congestion on Sutton Road and Willington
Street’.
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
H1 (9) – Bicknor Farm, Sutton
Road (335 units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation with the criterion amended as set out
in the papers and that at Criterion 12, paragraph vii be
added:
‘strategic road infrastructure to significantly relieve
traffic congestion on Sutton Road and Willington
Street’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (12) – Haynes, Ashford Road (250 units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation with a revised reduced yield of 200
units and incorporating the changes to the policy criterion as
follows:-
‘Provision will be made for publicly accessible open space
within the development site as part of the development layout and
contributions off-site where proven necessary’
And adding criterion:
‘The layout will be designed to ensure built development is
set-back from the Ashford Road frontage’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (13) – Medway Street, Maidstone (40
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation incorporating an
additional criterion as follows:-
‘The development layout will include significant landscaping
including tree planting’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (24) – West of Eclipse Park, Sittingbourne
Road (35 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation incorporating amended
criterion 2 as follows:-
‘A minimum 15 metre landscape buffer
shall be provided along the site’s western boundary adjacent
to the ancient woodland and no footpath, cycle or track-way shall
be provided within this safeguarded area’.
Additional criterion:
‘The layout and landscaping of the site shall be designed to
minimise the impact of development on the adjacent ancient woodland
to the west of the site through appropriate siting of the built development’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (29) – Tanyard Farm, Old
Ashford Road, Lenham (155 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to the
amended and additional criterions as per the papers and subject to
Ward Members being consulted on the landscaping issues:-
‘The hedgerow and line of trees along the northern and
southern boundaries of the site will be retained and substantially
enhanced by new planting in order to protect the setting of the
Kent Downs AONB, and to provide a suitable buffer between new
housing and the A20 Ashford Road and Old Ashford Road’.
‘The development proposals shall be designed to maintain
existing vistas and views of the Lenham Cross from Old Ashford
Road, through the site and along PROW KH433.
Development proposals shall incorporate substantial areas of
internal landscaping within the site to provide an appropriate
landscape framework for the site to protect the setting of the Kent
Downs AONB Development proposals will be of a highway standard of
design and sustainability reflecting the location of the site as
part of the setting the Kent Downs AONB incorporating the use of
vernacular materials and demonstrating compliance with the
requirements of policies DM2, DM3 and DM4.
The development proposals are designed to take into account the
results of a landscape and visual impact assessment undertaken in
accordance with the principles of current guidance that
particularly addresses the impact of development on the character
and setting of the Kent Downs AONB’.
6 – Agreed
H1 (36) – Hen and Duckhurst Farm, Marden Road, Staplehurst (370
units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation on a revised reduced yield of 250
units as per the papers. In addition
amend the Criterion 11 to:
‘appropriate contributions towards community strategic
infrastructure in particular foul water drainage will be provided
where proven necessary so that there is nil detriment to existing
infrastructure capacity’.
4 – Agreed
1 – Against
1 – Abstained
H1 (37) – Fishers Farm, Fishers Road, Staplehurst
(535 units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation on a revised reduced yield of a
maximum of 400 units. In addition amend the Criterion 11 to:
‘appropriate contributions towards community strategic
infrastructure in particular foul water drainage will be provided
where proven necessary so that there is nil detriment to existing
infrastructure capacity’.
An additional criterion as follows:-
‘The proposals will be designed to include areas of open
space that retain the integrity and connectivity of the existing
framework of ponds, hedgerows and trees within the
site’.
6 - Agreed
H1 (43) – Linden Farm, Stockett Lane, Coxheath (85 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation on a revised reduced
yield of 40 with an additional criterion as per the papers of
appropriate contributions towards improvements at the junction of
the B2163 Heath Road, with the A229 Linton Road/Linton Hill at
Linton Crossroads and a cascade criterion for community
infrastructure with investment in Coxheath first unless proven
otherwise.
6 – Agreed
H1 (44) – Heathfield,
Heath Road, Coxheath (130 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site go forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to amended
criterion as per the papers and a cascade criterion for community
infrastructure with investment in Coxheath first unless proven
otherwise.
H1 (26) – South of Ashford Road, Harrietsham (70
units)
RESOLVED: That this site go forward
to Regulation 19 consultation on the revised increased yield of 117
units and that an additional criterion be added as follows:-
‘The site layout is designed to fully integrate the
development and the proposed improvements to the A20 Ashford Road
to ensure a comprehensive approach to the improvements of the
public realm and highways safety’
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
(9)
Cabinet noted the recommendations of Planning, Transportation and
Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee as set out in the
tables of recommendations circulated as an Urgent
Update to the report of the Head of
Planning and Development relating to Regulation 18 Sites set out in
Appendix D which Committee recommended for further Regulation 18
consultation on deletion of the site from the Local Plan and made
the following decisions:-
H1 (17) – Barty Farm,
Roundwell (122 units)
RESOLVED: That Members
rejected the recommendation of the Committee and that the site go
forward to Regulation 19 consultation subject to amendment of the
site policy to respond to concerns about future primary education
provision and an additional criterion that Section 106
contributions are spent in Thurnham and
Bearsted first unless proven
otherwise.
5 – Agreed
1 – Against
H1 (20) – Postley
Road, Tovil (80
units)
RESOLVED: That Members
rejected the recommendation of the Committee and that the site go
forward to Regulation 19 consultation on the revised reduced yield
of 62 as per the papers.
4 – Agreed
1 - Against
1 - Abstained
6 – Agreed
H1 (25) – Tongs Meadow, West Street, Harrietsham (100
units)
RESOLVED: That Members, whilst
noting the concerns about ecology, were satisfied that there was
sufficient protection in the site policy and moved to reject the
recommendation of the Committee and that the site go forward to
Regulation 19 consultation with the amendments to criterion 4 as
per the papers and for a revised increased yield of 105.
5 – Agreed
1 – Against
H1 (30) – Glebe Gardens, Lenham (10 units)
RESOLVED: That Members rejected the
recommendation of the Committee and that the site go forward to
Regulation 19 consultation. It was
noted that the current planning application for this site provided
details of the proposed works to the pond and its environs and
other ecological surveys. These will be
considered as part of the application process by appropriate
consultees including the Environment
Agency and KCC Ecology, to-date no fundamental objections have been
raised to the principle of development as set out in the
policy.
6 – Agreed
H1 (31) – Ham Lane, Lenham (80
units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be rejected and go back to Regulation 18 consultation for
deletion on the grounds of unacceptably adverse impact on the AONB
and on the character of the village because it is peripheral to the
settlement and beyond the open space occupied by Swadelands School playing field.
4 – Agreed
2 – Against
H1 (39) – Ulcombe Road and Mill Bank, Headcorn (240
units)
RESOLVED: That Members
reject this site after further information was received at the
adjourned meeting which related to a drainage survey undertaken by
Headcorn Parish Council that detailed all the pipework across the Headcorn area. It was noted that a copy had been passed to
Southern Water. It was agreed to go
back to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion on the grounds that
local infrastructure is insufficient, in particular for foul water
sewerage, flood risk and highway congestion .
3 – Agreed
3 – Against
(Chairman had the casting vote)
H1 (41) – South of Grigg Lane, Headcorn (55
units)
RESOLVED: That this site be
rejected and go back to Regulation 18 consultation for deletion on
the grounds that local infrastructure is insufficient, in
particular for foul water sewerage, flood risk and highway
congestion.
3 – Agreed
2 – Against
1 – Abstained
H1 (42) Knaves Acre, Headcorn (5 units)
RESOLVED: That this
site be rejected and go back to Regulation 18 consultation for
deletion on the grounds that local infrastructure is insufficient,
in particular for foul water sewerage, flood risk and highway
congestion.
3 – Agreed
2 – Against
1 – Abstained
H1 (45) – Forstal Lane, Coxheath
(195 units)
RESOLVED: That Members
rejected the recommendation of the Committee and that the site go
forward to Regulation 19 consultation with the amended criterion as
per the papers of appropriate contributions towards improvements at
the junction of the B2163 Heath Road, with the A229 Linton
Road/Linton Hill at Linton Crossroads and a cascade criterion for
community infrastructure with investment in Coxheath first unless
proven otherwise.
3 – Agreed
2 – Against
1 – Abstained
(10)
That the shortfall of 2,556 homes against the already agreed
housing objectively assessed need of 18,600 was noted (for clarity
attached as Appendix A to this decision is a table setting out the
decision for the yield on each site) and Officers were asked to
bring a further report to Cabinet as soon as possible which
outlines the associated risks to the delivery of a sound Local
Plan; and
That Officers urgently progress dialogue with infrastructure
providers, particularly in relation to foul water, specifically
for
Headcorn and Staplehurst, to ensure that existing
infrastructure
concerns are addressed and works are progressed with the
utmost urgency.
Supporting documents:
-
Housing supply after Feb 2015 Cabinet, item 120.
PDF 51 KB View as HTML (120./1) 10 KB
-
RevisedAppB, item 120.
PDF 78 KB
-
Urgent Update - 1, item 120.
PDF 69 KB
-
Urgent Update - 2, item 120.
PDF 210 KB
-
Urgent Update - 3, item 120.
PDF 348 KB
-
Urgent Update - Revised Tables 2, item 120.
PDF 563 KB
-
Urgent Update - Revised Tables, item 120.
PDF 205 KB